Super Bowl Quarterbacks

Super Bowl XLIII is tomorrow.  So, I thought it might be a good exercise to review quarterback performances in each of the past 42 Super Bowls.  The first table below shows how each of the starting quarterbacks did.  Here are a few observations.

Quarterbacks in the Super Bowl make lots of mistakes.  Look at the quarterbacks on the losing team.  Until Super Bowl XXV between the Giants and Bills, every starting quarterback on a losing team had thrown at least one interception.  As a matter of fact, there have been only 4 times - Super Bowl XXV between the NY Giants and Buffalo Bills, Super Bowl XXXIV between the St Louis Rams and Tennessee Titans, Super Bowl XXXVIII between the New England Patriots and Carolina Panthers and last year's Super Bowl XLII between the NY Giants and New England Patriots, where the losing team's quarterback did not throw an interception.  When you think about each of these four games, one could make the argument that they all rank as the best played, most exciting and closest Super Bowls of all time.  

Starting QBs on the losing teams have thrown a total of 83 interceptions in the 42 games.  This compares to only 22 for starting QBs on the winning teams.  Don't throw an interception, and you give your team an excellent chance of winning the game.  Conversely, throw a pick, and you significantly reduce your team's chances of winning.  

Nine times the losing team's QB threw 3 picks; 4 times they threw 4 picks, and in Super Bowl XXXVII between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Oakland Raiders, Rich Gannon threw 5 picks.  That's 14 times in 42 games where a QB threw 3 or more INTs.  There's a 1/3 chance that tomorrow one of the two QBs will throw at least 3 picks!  

Three times the winning team's QB has thrown for more than 2 INTs.  In Super Bowl XIV, Pittsburgh's Terry Bradshaw threw 3, in Super Bowl XVII, Washington's Joe Theismann threw 2, and in Super Bowl XL, Ben Roethlisberger threw 2 INTs.  Note that Johnny Unitas threw 2 INTs in Super Bowl V as a back-up in a win over Dallas.

There have been 9 occasions where the winning team's QB threw for 3 or more TDs.  4 times they have thrown 3, 3 times they have thrown 4, and in Super Bowl XXIV, San Francisco's Joe Montana threw 5 TDs and in Super Bowl XXIX, San Francisco's Steve Young threw for 6 TDs against the San Diego Chargers.  It appears that not throwing INTs is probably more important than throwing TDs.  

The classic example of this is Super Bowl III, where NY Jets' Joe Namath guaranteed a victory against the Baltimore Colts.  He delivered.  He was named the game's MVP.  Most people don't realize that he didn't threw a single TD in that game.  Most importantly, he didn't throw an INT either.  

The table below shows (in my opinion) the 10 best and 10 worst performances by a starting QB over the past 42 Super Bowls.  It's difficult to compare QBs over time.  This is because the most commonly used measure to evaluate a QBs passing performance, the NFL Passer Rating system, has shown that the league average has been increasing over time (see here for the details).  

I have come up with a measure, CMI (Completions Minus Interceptions, calculated as Completion % - 3 * Interception Percentage), which I believe is a better measure of a QBs passing performance.  However, this measure also has the same problem that the Passer Rating formula has, in that it also shows that the league average has been increasing over time (see here).  One way to adjust for this trend is to relate each QBs performance in a Super Bowl to the overall league average for that year.  Then, one can compare that particular measure across Super Bowls.  If I had game-by-game data, I would not only relate the measure to the mean, but would also take into account the standard deviation.  However, in the absence of game-by-game data going back 42 years, the measure relative to the mean shall suffice.  Also, I eliminated from consideration any QB who attempted fewer than 15 passes during the game.

With the technical stuff all out of the way, the single best performance by a QB in a Super Bowl is Phil Simms for the NY Giants in Super Bowl XXI, when he went a near-perfect 22 of 25 with no INTs.  Interestingly, his QB Rating for that game was 150.9, close to the perfect rating of 158.3.  Steve Young's 6 TD effort doesn't show up in the Top 10, although Joe Montana's 5 TD effort does.

At the other end of the Spectrum, Craig Morton's 4 for 15 effort with 4 INTs in Super Bowl XII is the absolute worst performance by a QB in a Super Bowl by any measure.  He also has the dubious distinction of showing up twice on the 10 Worst Performances list.  Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh's QB in tomorrow's Super Bowl XLIII, is the only QB who shows up on the 10 Worst list, whose team actually won the game - Super Bowl XL against Seattle.