Anybody Looking for a Good QB?

Available:  Experienced quarterback with an accurate arm with ability to make immediate contributions to team; Ideally, would like to start, but not a requirement; may be perfect as back-up; durability maybe an issue.

I am referring of course to Jeff Garcia, released today by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.  I am personally a big fan of Garcia, because I believe he is underrated, and his achievements on the field have gone relatively unnoticed.

Let's take a look.

He began his NFL career in San Francisco in 1999, replacing not one, but two back-to-back Hall of Famers, and arguably the two greatest passers of all-time, Joe Montana and Steve Young.  There was no way Jeff could live up to those lofty expectations.  However, he did perform very well, as the table and chart below shows.  While he may not have performed at Joe Montana and Steve Young levels, his years in San Francisco were very productive.  After a sub-par year in 2003, he bounced around for three years, first as a starter in Cleveland (2004), then as a back-up in Detroit (2005) and Philly (2006).  He finished the 2006 season as the starter in Philadelphia for the last 6 games after Donovan McNabb got injured.  He showed that he could still play, and Tampa Bay, in need of a quarterback following an injury to Chris Simms, picked him up.  He did well above average each of 2007 and 2008, as you can see from the table and charts (he doesn't show up in the charts in the years 2004-2006 since he didn't attempt enough passes to qualify).  

Now, Tampa Bay, deciding to turn to the youth movement, have invested in Luke McCown, and, have deemed Garcia expendable.  

Garcia has been a very accurate as a passer throughout his career.  In a previous post, I discussed interceptions at length.  His 2007 season ranks 18th all-time (see Exhibit 3 in this post) in interceptions per attempt, in terms of standard deviations from the mean (his 2008 season ranks 118th, out of the 1,451 seasons in the database since 1940).  As a career passer, he ranks 12th all-time (see Exhibit 6 in this post).  By not throwing interceptions, he will help your team win.

I believe that Garcia has a couple of good years still left in him, if not as a starter, as a back-up.  His durability has been an issue the past two seasons, and hence, might be a liability as the starter.  

So who might be worthwhile candidates?

The following charts show, for each of 2007 and 2008, how a team's passing game stacked up in terms of standard deviations from the mean.  It's no coincidence that teams that were above average won more games than they lost, and teams that were below average lost more games than they won.  The charts show how the teams did both in terms of NFL passer rating and CMI.  Note that Garcia averaged 0.53 standard deviations above average in terms of NFL passer rating for the past two seasons, and averaged 1.23 standard deviations above average in terms of CMI.

To see which teams should be looking to get Garcia, let's start at the bottom, and move our way up.

Cleveland Browns - They have two young quarterbacks, Derek Anderson and Brady Quinn, both coming off season-ending injuries, that will compete for the starting job.  Not a candidate.  Look for another miserable year in Cleveland.

St Louis Rams - Marc Bulger is the starter, and for now at least, another soon-to-be 39 year-old - Trent Green, is the back-up.  Not a candidate.  By the way, what's happened to Bulger?  Will 2009 be more like his first few years, or his last two?  I suspect the latter.  Another long year in St Louis.

Oakland Raiders - Paying a lot of money for JaMarcus Russell.  They've also got Andrew Walter, Marques Tuiasosopo, and they just picked up Bruce Gradkowski off waivers.  I haven't a clue what the Raiders are doing, and I don't think the Raiders do either.  Not a candidate.  Perhaps we'll start paying attention when Al Davis passes away.

San Francisco Forty Niners - They're not sure who their starting quarterback is.  Shaun Hill?  J.T. O'Sullivan?  Alex Smith?  The niners maybe a candidate.  Garcia played here, and is originally from close-by Gilroy.

Detroit Lions - Daunte Culpepper is the starter.  Or is it Dan Orlovsky?  Didn't seem to matter in 2008, as they went 0-16.  If I was GM, I'd replace Culpepper with Garcia, and draft a quarterback.  But that's just me.  Garcia may not want to go here, but that's a different matter altogeher.

Chicago Bears - Kyle Orton is the starter, and Rex Grossman is the back-up.  Neither of whom are very good.  I would think that Garcia would be an excellent choice to be a back-up here.

Kansas City Chiefs - Tyler Thigpen is the starter.  Previous starter Damon Huard is the back-up.  Garcia could be a potential back-up here.

Cincinnati Bengals - Ryan Fitzpatrick finished the year as the starter, having replaced the injured Carson Palmer.  Not a candidate.

Of the remaining teams, perhaps the Minnesota Vikings might be interested.  Gus Frerotte is simply not a good option.  Maybe they'll lure Brett Favre out of retirement!  The NY Jets might be an option for Garcia as well.  Most likely, Kellen Clemens will be the starter, but Garcia could be a viable back-up here.  

So these are teams that should be interested in Garcia.  We'll wait and see where he actually ends up.